Life insurance plans
Rytvae Consulting · Insurance placed through IRDAI-regulated partners · Banashankari, Bengaluru
Most life insurance sold in India is not term insurance. The usual criticism of savings-linked policies is broadly fair — and there are still situations where they earn their place. How to tell which you are in.
Where savings-linked life insurance fits
Most life insurance sold in India is not term insurance. It is endowment, money-back, whole life or unit-linked — policies that combine a death benefit with a savings or investment element and return something if you survive.
The standard criticism is that combining protection with investment tends to do neither especially well: the cover is modest relative to the premium, and the investment is wrapped in charges and a long commitment. That criticism is broadly fair and worth stating plainly rather than talking around.
But it is not the whole picture. These policies do things term insurance and mutual funds cannot: they can provide a contractually defined outcome over a very long horizon, they enforce a discipline that some people genuinely need, they can be structured under the Married Women’s Property Act for creditor protection, and they serve estate and succession purposes where certainty matters more than return.
The honest position is that the product is neither a scandal nor a default. It answers a narrower set of questions than it is usually sold for, and the discipline is to know which question you are answering before you sign.
Endowment
A defined maturity benefit at the end of a term, plus death cover throughout. Certainty is the product.
Money-back
Periodic payouts through the term rather than a single maturity amount, with cover continuing.
Whole life
Cover extending to a very advanced age, used mainly for estate and succession purposes.
ULIP
Premium split between cover and market-linked funds you choose, with a five-year lock-in and defined charges.
Annuity
Converts a lump sum into a contractual income for life. The instrument for certainty in retirement.
Term
Pure protection, no maturity value, the highest cover per rupee. See our separate page.
Questions to ask before buying any of them
- What is the sum assured relative to the premium? If the cover is a small multiple of annual premium, this is a savings product with an insurance wrapper, and should be judged as one.
- What are the charges? ULIPs disclose premium allocation, policy administration, fund management and mortality charges. Traditional policies disclose less directly, which makes the illustration harder to interrogate.
- What happens if I stop paying? This is the question people skip and regret. Policies acquire a surrender value only after a minimum period, and the amount can be well below what has been paid in. IRDAI revised surrender value norms with effect from late 2024, improving early-exit values — but the principle stands that early exit costs money.
- Is the return guaranteed or illustrated? Illustrations show scenarios, not promises. Guaranteed components are what the contract actually commits to; the rest is projection.
- Could term plus a separate investment do this better? Sometimes yes, sometimes no. The point is to ask rather than to assume either way.
The tax position has narrowed
The exemption under Section 10(10D) has been progressively tightened, and several of the rules are recent enough that people are still working from outdated assumptions:
- For policies issued after a certain date, exemption requires the premium to stay within a prescribed proportion of the sum assured — a rule that catches high-premium, low-cover policies.
- ULIPs where aggregate annual premium exceeds a prescribed threshold are outside the exemption and are dealt with under the capital gains provisions.
- Traditional non-ULIP policies issued after a later date, where aggregate annual premium exceeds a separate prescribed threshold, are also outside the exemption.
- Death benefits continue to receive more favourable treatment than maturity proceeds.
Because these thresholds and dates have changed several times, do not rely on a figure quoted in any article, this one included, or in a sales illustration. Confirm the position for your specific policy, issue date and premium with your chartered accountant.
If you already hold a policy you regret
Surrendering is not automatically the right answer, and the decision should not be driven by irritation at having bought it.
Work out the surrender value now, what continuing would cost and what it would produce, and whether the cover itself is worth something to you — particularly if your health has changed since you bought it, in which case fresh cover may be expensive or unavailable. Consider making the policy paid-up: you stop paying, cover continues at a reduced sum assured, and nothing is surrendered. It is frequently better than either continuing or exiting.
Whatever you decide, do not surrender an existing policy before new cover is actually in force. The gap between the two is precisely when you are uninsured.
How Rytvae helps
We will tell you plainly when term insurance plus a separate investment answers your need better, and when a guaranteed or structured product genuinely earns its place. Where you already hold policies, we will work through whether to continue, make paid-up or exit, without pressure in either direction. Insurance is placed through our IRDAI-regulated partners.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between term insurance and a life insurance plan?
Term insurance is pure protection — it pays only on death and returns nothing if you survive, which is why the cover per rupee of premium is so high. Savings-linked plans combine a death benefit with a maturity or periodic payout, offering lower cover for the same premium.
Is it wrong to combine insurance and investment?
The standard criticism — that combining them does neither especially well — is broadly fair. But these policies can provide contractual certainty over very long horizons, enforce a discipline some people need, be structured under the MWP Act for creditor protection, and serve estate purposes. The discipline is knowing which question you are answering.
How do I judge whether a policy is mainly savings or mainly insurance?
Compare the sum assured to the annual premium. If the cover is only a small multiple of what you pay each year, it is a savings product with an insurance wrapper and should be judged on that basis.
What is a ULIP?
A unit-linked insurance plan, where premium is split between life cover and market-linked funds you select, with a five-year lock-in. Charges are disclosed separately — premium allocation, policy administration, fund management and mortality — which at least makes them interrogable.
What happens if I stop paying premiums?
Policies acquire a surrender value only after a minimum period, and the amount can be well below what you have paid in. IRDAI revised surrender value norms with effect from late 2024, improving early-exit values, but early exit still costs money.
What does making a policy paid-up mean?
You stop paying premiums, the policy continues at a reduced sum assured, and nothing is surrendered. It is frequently a better option than either continuing an unwanted policy or exiting it, particularly if your health has changed since you bought it.
Should I surrender a policy I regret buying?
Not automatically, and not out of irritation. Work out the surrender value, the cost and outcome of continuing, and whether the cover itself is worth keeping — especially if fresh cover would now be expensive or unavailable. Consider paid-up as a middle option.
Are life insurance maturity proceeds tax-free?
Not always. The Section 10(10D) exemption has been progressively tightened — with conditions on premium relative to sum assured, and separate premium thresholds above which ULIPs and traditional policies fall outside the exemption. Confirm the position for your specific policy, issue date and premium with your chartered accountant.
What is the difference between a guaranteed and an illustrated return?
Guaranteed components are what the contract actually commits to. Illustrations show scenarios under stated assumptions and are not promises. When comparing policies, compare the guaranteed elements first.
What is an annuity?
A product that converts a lump sum into a contractual income for life. It is the instrument for certainty in retirement, with no market risk and, correspondingly, no flexibility and generally no inflation indexing unless specifically purchased.
What is whole life insurance for?
Cover extending to a very advanced age, used mainly for estate and succession purposes rather than income replacement — typically where the intention is to leave a defined sum rather than to protect against premature death.
Can I hold both term and a savings-linked policy?
Yes, and for many people that is the sensible structure — adequate term cover for protection, with any savings-linked policy held for a specific purpose it genuinely serves rather than as the main protection.
Review what you already hold, without pressure
Continue, make paid-up or exit — we will work through the arithmetic with you either way.
Rytvae Consulting — AMFI Registered Mutual Fund Distributor (ARN-265474), EUIN E091320. Rytvae Consulting is a distributor of mutual fund and insurance products and is not a SEBI-registered Investment Adviser. Any assistance offered is incidental to distribution.
Insurance is the subject matter of solicitation. Cover, exclusions, waiting periods, limits and conditions differ between insurers and are governed entirely by the policy wording issued to you — read it before you rely on it. This page is general information, not advice on any specific policy, and not tax or legal advice. Taxation and regulatory positions depend on your own facts and on law as it stands from time to time; please confirm with your chartered accountant. Rytvae Consulting distributes insurance through IRDAI-regulated partners.
See our full disclosures and disclaimers.